BleacherCoaches.com

1. John Hayes- Football Coach (1980-Present)

2. Josh Kleinfelter- BA's All-Time Leading Rusher/Scorer-Runningback (2004-2006)

3. The Hoffer "Football" Family
-Mike Hoffer Football Coach 1970-74
-Scott Hoffer (Mike Hoffer's son) 1976 Blanket award winner
-Dan Houser (Mike Hoffer's Grandson/Scott Hoffer's Nephew) 2003 Blanket award winner
-Derrick Hoffer (Mike Hoffer's Grandson/Scott Hoffer's Son) 2004 Blanket award winner, All-State Defensiveback
-Dustin Hoffer (Mike Hoffer's Grandson/Scott Hoffer's Son) 2004 All-State Offensive lineman

4. Ron Blazier- Baseball Pitcher (Played for the Philadelphia Phillies)

5. Albert Dillen -Football Player 2nd All-Time in team scoring (1951-1954)

Not going to pretend to know a lot about their history, but do know John Hayes and Bud Grazier are first 2 and to me indisputable.

You could definately add Bud Grazier to that list